Skip to main content

Opinions


What if Christianity is a lie?


It really all starts with Paul, whose conversion on the road to Damascus predates the composition of all of the canonical gospels and exerted more influence than anyone else in the development of early Christianity. The way I see it is that there are three possibilities:


1. Jesus appeared to him in spirit and everything Paul claimed is accurate. This seems like the least likely to me.


2. Paul made it up to create a new religion and gain money and power, a la L. Ron Hubbard and Scientology. It’s even remotely possible (though exceedingly unlikely) that Paul made up the character of Jesus, as it’s true that there is no contemporary evidence or account of Jesus that predates Paul’s evangelism. While possible, Saul came from a fairly wealthy family and was on the path to becoming a leader and power broker among the Pharisees.


3. Paul suffered a very convincing hallucination. This to me is most likely. It’s not hard to imagine that Paul suffered heat stroke or even a small ischemic stroke on the road to Damascus and had a hallucination informed by a guilty conscience at his persecution of Jesus’ followers. Paul was well educated, and he literally puts phrases from Euripides’ The Bacchae into the mouth of Jesus during his supposed vision. 

Either the spirit of Jesus isn’t a very original orator, or Paul unconsciously gave Jesus words and attributes he associated with a living god, namely Dionysus. A stroke could also explain his alleged temporary loss of vision. Combining Paul’s upbringing in Tarsus and exposure to Hellenistic beliefs and practices with the teachings of Gamaliel and Hillel that he studied in Jerusalem, you’d get the syncretic beliefs of Christianity. If this is the case, the origin of Christianity as we know it wouldn’t be a lie exactly, but the result of a hallucination.


There have certainly been conmen throughout history willing to use religion to fleece their flocks, including the many televangelists and mega church “pastors” running around today in their private jets. Whether Paul was one of these hucksters or simply genuinely deluded, we’ll probably never know for sure.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Half a head

There were thin and bleak sounds, noises that were either real or imaginary. A sound of a wild bird in distress from a far, an owl maybe or a cardinal, accompanied by what sounded like uneasy movement and groaning noises from within. Those unnerving noises that make you believe hell is real and the damned has flung the gates open. He was in the police cell, the cell had huge shelves and guys were sleeping on the floor like they always do. You might have met this somewhere; you might have heard of it from the walls of your sitting room or the streets. It is a tale of this guy Boniface Kimanyano Ayoti, an epic face of crime, larger than life. A guy whose weakness was crime. Anything criminal triggered something in him. Something that not only made him content but also put him in a zone where nothing else could. Even though it can’t tell it all, Bonnie’s face is a tale of crime. Before you hear a word from him you know he’s not been an average human being. He has a swelling just above
21 comments
Read more

The Holy Studio

  I met Philip Mutemi in the streets of wanderlust diaries. He wrote a piece that caused stir and led to a lot of fuss. If you know the wanderlust diaries you're safe. You may actually go to heaven if Christ comes today. His display picture is of a man seated with arms crossed in what looks like a pub. A man probably past middle age. Looking at him another time, I feel like he has four children. Again looking at him, he doesn’t look like in 2014 he was 20 years old, I mean he almost looks older than my father. He honestly couldn’t be 30 right now. All these observations I made because of how some people in the comment section threw stones at him. So, Philip claims that back in 2014 his 3 cousins, 4 neighbours and himself were to join campus. They were given money to go and buy laptops. What is campus life without a laptop? The next Monday early in the morning they were in Nairobi. There was one cousin who was street smart and managed to convince them the he was well acquainted wi
12 comments
Read more

Major Ariel

Ariel studies Chemistry, but is also a footballer who retired prematurely because of a bad knee. A knee that chose chemistry over football. He is a farmer during long holidays. He keeps chicken and milk his father’s cow on a good day. On a bad day he goes to a nearby dusty arena to play football, to see if his knee could have possibly changed its idea about chemistry. Ten minutes into the  game he becomes a living testimony that his knees were actually meant to stand long hours in the chemistry lab doing tests and mixing chemicals to see colour changes, precipitates and what have you that don’t excite me. He is a vocabulary expert and a story teller. He is a fitness aficionado. He is a brother and a son. I can’t prove that he is a boyfriend but I can prove beyond any limits that in the past 7 days he has eaten chapatti at least thrice.  He's authored   THE FAMILY MAN ,   WHAT I WANT , GRIP REAPER ,  J'S COCUNUTS just to mention a handful. He is a huge Chelsea fan, a bruised te
24 comments
Read more